AWEJ Volume.5 Number.2, 2014                                                               Pp.244-257

Abstract PDF

Full Paper PDF  


The Effectiveness of Indirect Error Correction Feedback  on the Quality of Students’

Abdul Muth’im
Lambung Mangkurat University, Banjarmasin, Indonesia

 Mohammad Adnan Latief
State University of Malang, East Java, Indonesia


Giving feedback in the process of teaching writing is a common practice by writing teachers because it is believed to be able to help students write better. The feedback may be given directly or indirectly. The feedback may be given in the form of comments, questions, suggestions, and or corrections. It seems to be no dispute about the first three kinds of feedback. But for the corrections as the feedback in the process of teaching writing, there are two opposing views, one view believes that correction is counter-productive while the other view believes that correction is helpful. In this research, three kinds indirect correction feedback was implemented, sample end comment (SEC) feedback, coded correction (CC) feedback, and non-coded correction (NCC) feedback. Experimental research was used to find out which indirect correction feedback will give more effective result in the students’ writing quality.
Keywords: error correction feedback and writing quality.


Abdul Muth’im is a senior English lecturer at the English Department Lambung Mangkurat
University Banjarmasin, Indonesia. He got his Magister degree (1995) and Doctoral degree
(2013) in English education from State University of Malang, Indonesia. His research interest is
TEFL, especially writing. He has published two books “Developing Writing Skills from Theory
to Practice” (2009) and “Issues on language Teaching and Learning” (2010).